Naseeruddin Shah used the launch of a book on the pandemic to criticise how the lockdown was announced. According to PTI, the 76-year-old actor was speaking in Mumbai at the launch of “Trust in a Time of Crisis,” which documents the experiences of healthcare workers and volunteers, including a citizen-led relief effort in the city.
Shah read from the book, including a passage from the foreword by Indira Jaising about Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s announcement of a 21-day lockdown on March 24, 2020. He added that the attitude of the announcement was one of not expecting help from the government, followed by a remark about growing a beard and hair. The source text presents this as his own view; reports suggest he was reading and reacting to the foreword, so attribute it carefully.
The Tribute
Shah’s strongest words were for healthcare workers. He called those who died “martyrs” in the fight against an invisible enemy, said his heart was bursting with admiration and described how they upheld the oath they took. He said listening to doctors’ accounts was both eye-opening and distressing, and warned that future public health emergencies would require very different leadership skills and solutions.
The Government’s Position
Shah’s remarks are a critique, and the government has not responded in the reports I found. At the time, in March 2020, Modi addressed the issue directly. In his Mann Ki Baat of March 29, 2020, he apologised for the hardship caused by the lockdown, saying that in a country of 130 crore people it was the only option to ensure safety. His supporters have also described the lockdown as an early, decisive step. Critics, including Shah, have argued that the sudden announcement gave migrant workers and others little time to prepare, a view documented in several films and reports about the period.
A Separate Row
The source text links this event to Shah’s earlier video backing Jamia students, in which he wore a badge reading “Dimagi Naxal.” That row, covered earlier, involves different claims and responses and should not be confused with the book-launch remarks.
Why It Matters
Shah has been outspoken on several fronts in recent weeks, and this remark is about an episode many Indians remember vividly. It is also notable that he combined criticism with praise for frontline workers, which makes the remarks less one-sided than the headline suggests.
What Comes Next
Reactions from political figures and the book’s authors may follow. Bolly Orbit will update this report as developments emerge.